(Spoiler Warning: This review contains spoilers for The Devil Wears Prada 2.)
Anyone who knows me knows that I loved The Devil Wears Prada. It was an instant classic. From the character arcs and impossible assistant tasks to Stanley Tucci’s unmatched performance, it was a nearly flawless film.
To say I was disappointed by the much-anticipated sequel would be an understatement.
Please don’t get me wrong—there were certainly several redeeming qualities, including the fashion, Patrick Brammall’s witty and charming character, and Stanley Tucci’s return as the perfect supporting character that everyone roots for. Unfortunately, in my opinion, the three female leads fell flat.
Part of what made The Devil Wears Prada such an incredible film was its character development. You watched Andy (Anne Hathaway) come into her own and gain not only confidence but also a sense of self-worth, while still remaining grounded. At the same time, both Miranda Priestly (Meryl Streep) and Emily (Emily Blunt) softened in subtle but meaningful ways.
It was disappointing to see old patterns return with little indication that those hard-earned lessons remained.
Watching the empowered and passionate writer Andy had become fall back into seeking validation from her former boss was frustrating. Seeing her pace outside Miranda’s office like a child waiting for a gold star felt like a complete reversal of the growth she experienced in the original film.
While some of that growth returns as the story progresses, the damage had already been done.
As for Miranda, I have no trouble believing that someone of her stature might not immediately remember a former employee. However, someone who walked out during Paris Fashion Week would hardly be forgotten after twenty years. Frankly, I expected more resistance to Andy’s return than what the film ultimately presented.
Revenge is certainly one of the film’s major themes. It is a concept that resonates because it allows audiences to imagine what they might do if given the opportunity. Would you seek revenge if you had the chance? Many people would probably say no, but I suspect more people would embrace that opportunity than admit it.
Emily embodies that theme throughout the film.
She sees an opportunity and grabs it with both hands. She refuses to back down when the chance arises to push Miranda out of power. However, the way she chooses to achieve her goals surprised me. Lowering herself to become the arm candy of a wealthy, uninspiring man felt out of character.
The Emily we came to know and love in the original film seemed stronger than that. Still, the writers clearly had a different vision for her.
Without question, the absolute best part of this movie is Nigel (Stanley Tucci).
Not only does he retain the wit, sarcasm, and charm that made him a fan favorite in the original, but he finally receives the recognition he deserves. After decades of loyalty and being overlooked, Nigel finally gets his moment to shine.
Even more importantly, Nigel demonstrates his true character in the film’s final act, revealing just how Andy returned to Runway in a twist that may be somewhat predictable but is nevertheless heartfelt and satisfying.
Nigel makes this movie worth watching.
Many readers may notice that I have not spent much time discussing Stuart (Kenneth Branagh), Sasha (Lucy Liu), Jay (B.J. Novak), Amarsi (Simone Ashley), or Charlie (Caleb Hearon). That is not because their performances were unimportant. Rather, my focus has been on comparing this sequel to the original and examining the journeys of Miranda, Andy, Emily, and Nigel.
Yes, I have spent much of this review criticizing the film.
However, despite its flaws, The Devil Wears Prada 2 is not a bad sequel. It may not fully live up to the original, and it may have been somewhat overhyped, but it still offers enough enjoyable moments to make it worth watching.
For longtime fans of the original film, particularly those who have remained invested in these characters over the past two decades, there is enough here to justify the return trip to Runway. While I may not agree with every creative decision, I have no hesitation recommending it to fans of the original.
Rating: ★★★½ out of ★★★★★
You must be logged in to post a comment Login